Sunday, July 31, 2011

Man convicted of killing bank teller during robbery


An accused head of a stick-up crew that robbed small restaurants and banks at gunpoint was found guilty today by a federal jury in Chicago of fatally shooting a bank teller during a 2007 holdup of a South Side bank.

David Vance gunned down teller Tramaine Gibson, 23, after he was unable to open a vault during the robbery at the Illinois Service Federal Savings and Loan in Chatham in May 2007. Two accomplices engaged in a shootout with a security guard, wounding him and an elderly customer in the bank.

The government presented DNA evidence, videotape surveillance of the robbery and eyewitnesses to the holdup.

Vance's co-defendant, Alton Marshall, who pleaded guilty to avert the death penalty, testified for the prosecution, identifying Vance as an accomplice.

Man charged in two shooting deaths in Chatham









David Russell

David Russell (Police photo)









Chicago police have charged a Far South Side man in the shooting deaths of two people in the Chatham neighborhood Friday.


David A. Russell, 22, of the 9500 block of South Calumet Avenue in Chicago in the Rosemoor neighborhood, was charged with two counts of first degree murder and two counts of attempted first degree murder in the killings, according to a news release from police today.


Russell had been in police custody since the day of the shooting and will appear in bond court today. Another man who had been in custody was released without charges, police said.


The shooting occurred around 3:30 p.m. Friday near 82nd Street and Cottage Grove Avenue on the South Side. As many as three beat patrol officers were talking outside a bank near 83rd and Cottage when they saw a man shoot a woman, then open fire on a man she was with, officials said.


The gunman then shot at the officers, but missed, authorities said. The officers pursued the gunman, who fled with another man in a vehicle that then crashed at 82nd Street and Drexel Avenue, authorities said.


Shots were fired by police at some point during their confrontation with the gunman, but he wasn't wounded. The gunman and the other man were taken into custody near 86th Street and Ingleside Avenue.


Kenneth Taylor, 24, of the 8300 bock of South Maryland Avenue in Chicago, and Moneet Baker, 22, of the 8200 block of South Drexel Avenue in Chicago, were the two shooting victims.

Wednesday, July 27, 2011

Man charged in killing of Chicago cop, a former resident of Park Manor









Man charged in killing of Chicago police officer

Antwon Carter (left) is charged with the 2010 killing of Chicago Police Officer Michael Bailey (right). (July 26, 2011)







A 24-year-old man was charged today with gunning down an off-dutyChicago police officer who was about to retire after 20 years on the force, authorities said.

Officer Michael Bailey was cleaning his new Buick – a retirement gift to himself – outside his South Side home in July 2010 when he was killed in an exchange of gunfire with a would-be robber, police said. He was still in uniform after just working an overnight shift.

The suspect, Antwon Carter, was charged late today with first-degree murder and attempted armed robbery, according to Sally Daly, spokeswoman for the Cook County state’s attorney’s office.

The charges come about three weeks afterChicago police questioned Carter about the veteran officer’s murder -- a development first reported by the Tribune.

Carter was on parole for aggravated battery to another police officer when he allegedly shot Bailey to death during the attempted robbery, according to court records. Carter was arrested two months after Bailey’s murder on unrelated carjacking and weapons charges and has remained in state prison since then for violating his parole, the records show.

Bailey, 62, had finished his shift guarding the home of then-Chicago Mayor Richard Daley when he was shot at about 6 a.m. on Sunday, July 18, 2010, in front of his Park Manor neighborhood home.

The break in the case came after Carter talked about killing the officer to several other witnesses, law enforcement sources said. Investigators also discovered letters handwritten by Carter implicating himself in the murder, the sources said.

Bailey, who was assigned to the Central Police District, was about a month from turning 63, the department’s mandatory retirement age, when he was killed.

Tuesday, July 26, 2011

Walmart Express hits Chicago and Chatham










(July 26, 2011)





CHICAGO (Reuters) - Wal-Mart Stores Inc is opening its first small store in Chicago this week in the first true test of a store format the world's largest retailer hopes will let it penetrate urban markets that it so far has had trouble cracking.

Wal-Mart will open its first small urban store, less than one-tenth the size of a traditional Walmart, in the city's Chatham neighborhood on Wednesday.

Four more Walmart Express stores are planned for Chicago, along with three larger Walmart Market stores, which are more like traditional grocery stores, and two more Walmart supercenters. Its first Walmart supercenter opened in 2006.

The Chicago stores, and small stores in Arkansas and North Carolina, are quickly opening up as Wal-Mart tries to reverse two years of declining sales at existing U.S. discount stores.

The chain is trying to win back shoppers, especially those on limited budgets, who have started to do more of their shopping at chains such as Family Dollar Stores Inc that pack a variety of food and basic goods into small shops.

"I think it's fair to say there's a multibillion dollar growth opportunity in a lot of these cities and Wal-Mart just hasn't had the right format to penetrate," said Natalie Berg, global research director at Planet Retail.

The new Walmart Express format is being overseen by Anthony Hucker, vice president of strategy and business development, who is no stranger to opening up small discount shops. Before he joined Wal-Mart, Hucker spent a decade at German deep discount chain Aldi, including time setting up that retailer's stores in the United Kingdom.

Aldi stocks only its own store branded goods, while Walmart Express has Wal-Mart's Great Value brand as well as goods from the likes of Coca-Cola Co , Kraft Foods Inc and Procter & Gamble Co . Hucker said that people are happy to see brands that they know.

Wal-Mart just started to test the Walmart Express format last month by opening stores in rural parts of Arkansas and North Carolina.

While Wal-Mart is "very, very pleased" with early results from those stores, setting up shop in cities such as Chicago and trying to enter cities such as New York is different.

It costs more to open a store in a city than in a rural area, as rents can be two to three times more expensive, Hucker said as he walked through the new store on Tuesday.

There are also logistical issues to consider, such as dealing with some tighter spaces within the store and traffic when trucks bring in goods, he said.

"If they can't get the store economics right then the format really doesn't have a future," said Berg. "There's going to be a lot of pressure on keeping costs down."

Wal-Mart's heft, with more than 9,200 stores across the globe, is likely to give it an edge over urban competitors.

"They're the largest retailer in the world, so from a pricing perspective they can compete with anyone," said Steve Ferrara, partner in the retail and consumer practice at BDO USA in Chicago.

The day before the grand opening, workers were busy loading produce, chips, beer and other goods in the 10,000-square foot store and putting up signs touting locally grown produce.

Wal-Mart is starting to buy more from local companies, a move that highlights its environmental efforts and cuts down on distribution costs. The first items shoppers will see when they enter the store this week are cantaloupes from Illinois' Frey Farms, as well as mini watermelons.

The store already has some competition, with a new Aldi open nearby and other chains not too far away, such as Walgreen Co .

Wal-Mart has just one supercenter in Chicago so far, miles away in the Austin neighborhood. Its next supercenter will open next spring, right in the same shopping area as the new Walmart Express.

First Walmart Express to open Wednesday



First Walmart Express to open Wednesday
The nation's first urban Walmart Express store is slated to open Wednesday on Chicago's South Side, part of a highly anticipated test that Wal-Mart Stores Inc. hopes will help turn around a two-year U.S. sales slump.

The world's largest retailer, best known for its football field-size supercenters, plans to roll out 15 Walmart Express stores this year in three test markets: Chicago, Richfield, N.C., and the discount chain's home state of Arkansas. The small stores, typically 10,000 to 15,000 square feet, are one-tenth the size of a standard Walmart supercenter and carry fresh groceries, pharmacy and health and beauty aids.






The new convenience format is aimed at staving off the rise of dollar stores, which thrived during the recession and continue to draw customers away from Wal-Mart Stores, analysts said. The Bentonville, Ark.-based company has had to rely on overseas stores to fuel revenue growth as same-stores sales at its U.S. stores, its biggest division, have slipped for eight consecutive quarters.

"This is Wal-Mart going on the offensive," said Jim Hertel, managing partner at Willard Bishop, a Barrington-based grocery store consulting firm. "They're using these little stores as a way to combat the pesky little competitors that are opening up everywhere."

Wal-Mart plans to open five stores in each test market. The company already has signed leases for four of the five Chicago locations. The first store, opening Wednesday, is located on the outskirts of Chatham Market, a shopping center at 83rd Street and Stewart Avenue on the South Side. A Walmart supercenter, slated to open next year, is also under construction at Chatham Market.

The other Chicago Express locations are at Broadway and Addison streets in Wrigleyville, scheduled to open later this year; at South Western Avenue and West 71st Street, slated to open early next year; and at Chicago Avenue and Franklin Street, scheduled to open in the spring of 2012.

Wal-Mart breaks ground on Chatham store



Wal-Mart breaks ground on Chatham store
Wal-Mart Stores Inc. yesterday broke ground on a new supercenter in Chatham, one of nine new locations now planned in the city.

The South Side store, expected to employ about 400, is scheduled to open in spring of 2012.






Wal-Mart officials were joined by Alderman Howard Brookins and other community stakeholders at a groundbreaking event Monday at 83rd Street and Stewart Avenue.

"This day has been a long time coming," said Alderman Brookins. "This supercenter will help residents living in nearby food deserts have easy access to reasonably priced quality produce."

According to Julie Murphy, senior vice president of Wal-Mart U.S., the Chatham site was an important step in allowing Walmart to pursue additional opportunities to spur local economic development in the city of Chicago.

"The approval of this store helped pave the way for additional opportunities," said Murphy. "Wal-Mart is committed to creating 10,000 new jobs throughout Chicago."

In June 2010, Wal-Martsaid it was embarking on a five-year plan to open several dozen stores, creating approximately 10,000 jobs and generating more than $500 million in sales and property taxes.

Wal-Mart's plans in the city include the following projects:

  • Supercenter in Pullman at 111th St. and South Doty Ave. (spring 2013)
  • Supercenter in West Chatham at 83rd Street and Stewart Avenue (spring 2012)
  • Walmart Market in the West Loop at West Monroe St. and South Jefferson Street (fall 2011)
  • Walmart Market in West Englewood at West 76th Street and South Ashland Avenue (spring 2012)
  • Walmart Market in Lake View at Broadway and Surf (winter 2012)
  • Walmart Express in West Englewood at South Western Ave. and West 71st Street (winter 2012)
  • Walmart Express in West Chatham at 83rd Street and Stewart Avenue (summer 2011)
  • Walmart Express in River North at Franklin and Chicago Avenues (fall 2011)
  • Walmart Express in Wrigleyville at Broadway and Addison (winter 2011)


Monday, July 18, 2011

2 wounded in fatal bank robbery testify: Security guard, customer describe 2007 heist in Chatham










David Vance (July 15, 2011)



Earl Coleman was calm as he described in court Thursday a gun battle that unfolded when three masked robbers stormed the Chatham neighborhood bank where he worked as a security guard in May 2007.


"As soon as I stepped from behind that partition, they started firing," Coleman said on the witness stand in U.S. District Judge Joan Gottschall's courtroom.


Coleman, a veteran of more than a decade at the Illinois Service Federal Savings and Loan at 87th Street and King Drive, testified he dropped to the floor as one robber leaped over a teller counter and brandished a .357 Smith & Wesson. With both hands on his weapon, Coleman said, he fired six shots at the robbers before they fled the bank with only a teller drawer containing $6,875.







A teller, Tramaine Gibson, 23, was killed, while Coleman and a customer, Dorothy Sanders, a retired teacher, were wounded. Sanders also testified Thursday at the trial of David Vance, who is charged with fatally shooting Gibson after he was unable to unlock the bank vault. Two robbers previously pleaded guilty.


Sanders said she was rising from a seat in the branch manager's cubicle when she saw a man run by and realized a bank robbery was under way. Sanders said she stuck her wallet inside her bra for safekeeping.


"I started standing up, getting ready to go out the door," she told the jury. "Next thing I knew, I was in the ambulance."


Sanders spoke softly as she described the gunshot wounds to her left arm and the bullets that ended up lodged in her right side.


Coleman said he first realized the bank was being robbed when one of the masked men jumped over the teller counter.


"The only way I knew they were armed was when they started shooting at me," Coleman said as prosecutors displayed an enlarged surveillance photo of the gunmen on a screen.


Coleman was shot once each in the chest and left leg.


Vance's attorney Paul Brayman asked Coleman if he remembered telling FBI agents after the shootout that he had shot one of the robbers.


"Four years ago? No, I cannot remember," Coleman said. "I was heavily sedated after having been shot twice."

Wounded victims describe fatal bank robbery










David Vance

David Vance (Tribune file / July 14, 2011)




A retired school teacher and security guard calmly recounted in federal court today how they were shot and wounded four years ago when three masked men stormed into a Chatham neighborhood bank.


One of the alleged suspects, David Vance, is on trial in federal court in connection with the takeover robbery in which teller Tramaine Gibson was fatally shot.


Customer Dorothy Sanders told jurors she realized a bank robbery was underway that day in May 2007 when she saw a man running inside Illinois Federal Savings and Loan as she met with the branch manager.







"I started standing up, getting ready to go out the door," she recalled. “I knew I was in a bank robbery, so that's why I put my wallet in my bra. ... Next thing I knew I was in the ambulance."


Vance allegedly shot Gibson, 23, after he was unable to open a vault in the bank in the 8700 block of South Martin Luther King Drive. Two accomplices engaged in a shootout, wounding Sanders and a security guard.


Sanders described softly but matter-of-factly the gunshot wounds to her left arm that ended up lodged in her right side.


The security guard, Earl Coleman, also testified today that he was shot twice as he exchanged fire with the gunmen.


"The first thing I saw was one of the bank robbers jump over the teller counter," Coleman said as an enlarged image of surveillance tape of the armed gunman was displayed on a screen in the federal courtroom.


"The only way I knew they was armed was when they started shooting at me," Coleman said of the three suspects.


Coleman, who had worked at the bank since 2000, said he fired six shots from his .357 Smith and Wesson.

Trial begins in 4-year-old fatal bank robbery: Shooting death of bank teller was 'coldblooded murder,' jury told





"Murder," announced Assistant U.S. Attorney Andrianna Kastanek as she began her opening remarks in dramatic fashion at a trial into the Chicago area's first fatal bank robbery in years. She then paused to let the word sink in before continuing: "Coldblooded murder."


Kastanek went onto describe how David Vance allegedly fatally shot teller Tramaine Gibson, 23, after he failed to open a vault during the robbery at the Illinois Service Federal Savings and Loan in Chatham in May 2007. Two accomplices engaged in a shootout, wounding a security guard and a customer.


Kastanek told the federal jury that the government would present DNA evidence, videotape surveillance of the robbery and eyewitnesses to the holdup. Vance's co-defendant Alton Marshall, who has already pleaded guilty in the case so that he could avoid the death penalty, will also testify, she said.







But Vance's attorney, Ellen Domph, attacked Marshall's credibility, calling him a "habitual liar" and "career offender" who is looking out for his best interest.


Domph told jurors that the government's forensic evidence — including a glove that contains DNA matches for both Gibson and Vance — was flawed because the FBI bungled the collection process. She said the FBI placed five clumps of latex gloves found near the robbery scene in the same plastic bag and miscounted the number of gloves found at the scene.


The first government witness, Nicole Morgan, 39, the bank's assistant branch manager, testified she was walking a client from her work cubicle when three masked men with guns stormed in. Morgan said she and the customer dropped to the floor as shots rang out.


Morgan, who was stone-faced and spoke with a steady voice as she was questioned, said she "saw the feet" of the gunmen leave the bank. That's when she saw the customer had been shot. Morgan then discovered a security guard had been shot in the leg and Gibson was mortally wounded.

Blog Question

Are you afraid and fearful of the loitering youths on 79Th Street between King Drive and Cottage Grove Avenue, transient young people who walk the streets at night, creating anxieties about the influx of young people of color from the torn-down projects and other areas of the city into Chatham? Should police crack down on these youths? And are you sick and tired of the so-called businesses up and down 79Th Street that cater to these youths to stay in the neighborhood? Leave your comment on the comment line.

Wednesday, July 13, 2011

Bikers accused in bomb, death plots: Federal indictment names 7 members in Chicago area



Members of the Wheels of Soul motorcycle gang weren't shy about using violence, according to a federal indictment unsealed Tuesday.



They were ordered to carry guns, knives and hammers, and were involved in shootings, stabbings and a plan to blow up a rival gang with a pipe bomb, according to the indictment.


Eighteen alleged gang members, seven from the Chicago area, were charged in a sweeping racketeering indictment handed down by a federal grand jury in St. Louis on June 9. Other alleged gang members were from Pennsylvania, Ohio, Missouri, Colorado, Wisconsin and Kentucky.







Among the alleged members from Chicago is Anthony Robinson, 24, who is charged with committing a murder as part of the criminal conspiracy. According to the indictment, Robinson, a "regional enforcer" in the gang, fatally shot a man during a Jan. 2 melee with members of a rival gang.


The shooting occurred at a motorcycle club in the West Chatham neighborhood on Chicago's South Side. Two men, Bryant Glass, 39, and Emmit Suddoth, 38, were killed in the shooting — the indictment did not make it clear which slaying Robinson is charged with.


Allan Hunter, 33, of Wheaton, is charged in the indictment with conspiracy to commit murder for taking part in an alleged plan in February to take out members of a rival Chicago motorcycle gang with a pipe bomb. The bombing never took place, according to the indictment.


Hunter took over as the Wheel of Soul's Midwest region president after Myron Farris, 38, was shot and killed in his garage on the West Side in July, 2010, according to the indictment.


Hunter also is accused in a January plot to murder members of a rival gang in East St. Louis, Ill., and, with Robinson, of attempted murder in connection with a March shooting in Ohio. Robinson is also charged with murder in that shooting.


The other Chicago members charged are Maurice Thomas, 31; Toney Sims, 39; Thomas Bailey, 41; Carlyle Fleming, 32: and Bryant Palmer, 51. All are charged with racketeering. Thomas, Sims, Bailey and Palmer are also charged with drug offenses.


Fleming is charged with attempted murder as part of the conspiracy in the August 2009 shooting of a man identified in the indictment only as R.T. in a Chicago club called the Howling Moon.


In a separate indictment that came out of the same investigation, two Chicago-area men were charged with firearms offenses.

Father of slain bank teller sees case go to trial after four years Devoted dad has been a fixture at courthouse



















Verton Gibson Jr. says he has sat through so many hearings and absorbed so much legal minutia because “I just want everyone to know that Tramaine is represented.” (Antonio Perez, Chicago Tribune / July 12, 2011)





Verton Gibson Jr. can't count how many times he has traveled from his South Side home to the looming glass-and-steel federal courthouse downtown since May 22, 2007.

That was the day his son, Tramaine, 23, was gunned down during a takeover robbery at a Chatham bank, the first teller to be killed in a Chicago-area holdup in years.











On Monday, on the eve of the trial of the suspect in his son's slaying, Gibson once again jumped on the Red Line and hurried to the Dirksen U.S. Courthouse — just as he has dozens of times in the last four years — to be sure he wouldn't miss a hearing in the case.

For 40 minutes, he listened as the judge and attorneys bantered about the expected evidence and expert testimony. And when it was over, Gibson gathered in the hall with prosecutors, who greeted him like an old friend and asked him if he had any questions.

He confirmed with them when jury selection would begin Tuesday and then offered a little advice.

"Eat your Wheaties," he said with a smile before heading downstairs.

"I'm here for my son," Gibson said moments later. "I have been told that a lot of people don't even come. They just wait until the trial. I just want everyone to know that Tramaine is represented, each and every court hearing.

"The defense attorneys are there. The government is there. So I feel someone from his family should be here. …He would have done it for me. You can believe that."

Bank robberies — particularly takeovers in which armed robbers hurdle teller counters and seize control — are violent, frightening experiences for employees and customers but are rarely deadly. Gibson's son was one of only four bank employees or guards to be killed in the thousands of bank robberies across the country in 2007.

And FBI officials in Chicago can't even recall the last fatal bank robbery in the Chicago area before Gibson was slain when three masked gunmen stormed the Illinois Service Federal Savings and Loan, 8700 S. Drive.

Prosecutors allege that Henry Bluford stood lookout at the front door as Alton Marshall kept watch over security guards and David Vance rushed the tellers at about 9:30 a.m.

But things went horribly wrong.

Marshall disarmed a security guard, and Vance, armed with a long-barreled revolver, shot Tramaine Gibson in the lower back when he was unable to open the vault door, authorities allege. Vance then allegedly dragged the mortally wounded Gibson toward the vault.

In the meantime, Bluford and Marshall exchanged gunfire with a second security guard. Both the guard and a customer, a 74-year-old retired teacher, were wounded as dozens of shots were fired. The three fled with a teller drawer containing about $6,900 in cash, according to authorities.

The suspects had planned to rob the bank three days earlier but held off because a parade had drawn a heavy police presence near the bank, according to court records.

A $50,000 reward led to a tip from an acquaintance of one of the gunmen who then with the help of authorities secretly recorded Marshall making admissions about the holdup. When confronted by investigators, Marshall quickly confessed and implicated his accomplices. He and Bluford pleaded guilty and agreed to testify against Vance in return for sharply reduced prison terms. Vance, who has pleaded not guilty and denied involvement in the deadly holdup, faces life in prison if convicted by the federal jury.

It has taken four years — an unusually long time at federal court for a case of this kind — to move to trial. And bit by bit, Verton Gibson, who is head of security at an elementary school, has absorbed the arcane legal process. By now, he has learned the jargon of the courtroom, easily describing a judge's ruling or following trial strategies. He has met with U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald.

When Bluford pleaded guilty nearly two years ago, Gibson was shocked to hear he likely faced just a 20-year prison sentence. In an unusual moment for that stage of the proceedings, Gibson was allowed to address his concerns in court to U.S. District Judge Joan Gottschall, who is presiding over the case.

It has been a long four years for Gibson, who has watched patiently in court as the attorneys and judge worked over minute details to ensure Vance obtains a fair trial. At times, he has sat directly in front of the defendants' families and overheard their observations about what was happening, he said.

He has wondered about the times Vance wasn't even present in court — imprisoned defendants awaiting trial have a right to waive appearances at hearings — when Gibson himself had "slipped and slided over ice" to be there for hearings in winter.

What he didn't hear much about over these years was his son, who despite growing up in one of the city's toughest neighborhoods was carving out a good life, with a promising job at a bank and a young family. The younger Gibson was also attending college and planned to buy a home to live in with his wife and two young children, one of whom finished kindergarten this year.

"Everything is geared toward the defendant," Gibson said. "They have this right. They have that right. And we want them to have a good trial. But the fact remains that the only thing Tramaine did when he got up that morning was he kissed his family goodbye and he went to work. Who anticipated dying at work?"

At the hearing Monday, federal prosecutors and Vance's attorneys debated whether a particular expert was qualified to testify. The two sides also argued about whether the defense could raise questions at trial about evidence it contends was lost.

Sitting on a bench in the courtroom, Gibson took it all in. He's been coming here long enough to figure out what lies ahead.

"That's (their) job to pick holes or find something wrong," he said of Vance's lawyers. "I just don't know, I just don't know. When the trial starts, I guess it will all come out."

Thursday, July 7, 2011

Blog Question

Do you think young black people visiting the neighborhood from other parts of the city are the source of the riff-raft and the crime wave in Chatham? Leave your comment on the comment line.

Wednesday, July 6, 2011

Take Note

The new aldermanic office for the new 6th Ward Alderman Roderick T. Sawyer is located in Chatham at 463 & 1/2 East 83rd Street, phone (773) 635-0006.

Blog Question

Now with the new Aldi Superstore and the Walmart Express open or due to be open this summer, and with the Walmart Superstore due to be open next spring, do you think the Chatham Market should vie for a Costco Wholesale outlet, a Trader Joe's, and a Whole Foods Market? Leave your comments on the comment line.